Award-winning and critically acclaimed country star Carly Pearce has unveiled the latest single from her upcoming album, Honest Woman, and the track should be of special interest not just to country fans, but bluegrass lovers, too. “What If You Loved Me,” available today on streaming platforms and via an accompanying performance video (watch above) features Dan Tyminski and Molly Tuttle on harmony vocals and mandolin and clawhammer banjo, respectively. It’s a lovely song of longing daydreaming and Pearce’s lead vocal shines bolstered by such talented and artful harmony singers.

“What If You Loved Me” is built on an absolutely classic country trope, the “opposite day” paradigm, asking seemingly simple but actually huge and daunting questions. It immediately recalls songs like Dolly Parton’s “The Grass Is Blue,” Zach Top’s “I Never Lie,” George Jones’ “She Thinks I Still Care” or “Just Someone I Used to Know” written by Cowboy Jack Clement, wherein the speaker says exactly what they want, dream of, hope for, and love – but by pointing out the opposite of each. Pearce’s incisive song is a lovely iteration on this age-old country theme, singing:

What if up was down and down was up
And you were the sad one
And I already found somebody?
What if I didn’t love you
And what if you loved me? 

It’s a heart-wrenching plea, the lonesome pining in the lyrics ratcheted to extremes by delicious, buttery three-part harmony. With Pearce on rhythm guitar, Tuttle picks up an open-back old-time banjo and frails along while Tyminski pulls limitless emotion from his mandolin with tremolos and tender licks. Both of these bluegrass pickers are accomplished multi-instrumentalists, serving any and every song and context in whatever way they need.

“Bluegrass is such a cherished part of who I am as it’s where I got my start,” says Pearce via press release. “To record a song that honors my roots with two artists that I have deep respect and admiration for is not only a special moment, but very emotional. 10-year-old Carly who grew up singing in bluegrass bands would be over the moon to know she has a song with Dan and Molly (as is present-day Carly!). This is the perfect moment in my career to show fans this side of my heart.”

It’s easy to trace the bluegrass influences through Carly Pearce’s country career, as the genre has been an important part of the Kentucky native’s creative life all along. But it’s especially apparent lately, with this collaboration with Tyminski and Tuttle, another track on Honest Woman featuring Tyminski as well, and Pearce’s recent CMA Fest appearance that featured Tuttle, Ricky Skaggs, young mandolinist Shay Morgan, and members of Skaggs’ band, Kentucky Thunder. Their performance of “From Now On” was a hit at Nissan Stadium and on the CMA Fest broadcast on ABC, too.

Bluegrass and country have always gone hand-in-hand, but with excellent songs such as these, artists like Carly Pearce help remind of their inseparable connection. Pearce’s brand new album, Honest Woman, will be out August 28 and her Honest Woman: Up Close Tour beings in September.

Photo Credit: John Shearer